How Would A Politician Do it?

Sue Lowden is the leading candidate in the Nevada Republican primary to pick a challenger to Harry Reid. She was widely expected to win the primary, and go on to defeat Reid in November.

But that was before she began to spell out her views on how the American health care system can be improved. Ten days ago, she said she believes that the way to hold down medical costs is to move from the current system of paying doctors with cash, check or credit card to a barter system:

And I would have suggested, and I think that bartering is really good. Those doctors who you pay cash, you can barter, and that would get prices down in a hurry. And I would say go out, go ahead out and pay cash for whatever your medical needs are, and go ahead and barter with your doctor.

That statement elicited a certain amount of ridicule, and a certain amount of sheer disbelief (“she couldn’t have really meant barter, she probably meant bargain“). So this week Lowden clarified that she meant exactly what she had said:

I’m telling you that this works. You know, before we all started having health care, in the olden days our grandparents, they would bring a chicken to the doctor, they would say I’ll paint your house. I mean, that’s the old days of what people would do to get health care with your doctors. Doctors are very sympathetic people. I’m not backing down from that system.

It’s all very well for chicken farmers, but what’s a blogger to barter with?

Or a politician? I can see Lowden going to the doctor next week, and going: “How about you give me credit now, and once I’m elected, I’ll repeat on the Senate floor any five lies of your choice?”

Comments

  1. EqualOpportunityCyni says:

    I can see Lowden going to the doctor next week, and going: “How about you give me credit now, and once I’m elected, I’ll repeat on the Senate floor any five lies of your choice?”

    Sue Lowden has money. She doesn’t have to worry about actually bartering for her own health care. She was just suggesting a system for the little people.

  2. sarabeth says:

    Hey, bartering saves money! Even people with money love to save money.

    If you were a senator, how would you rather pay your doctor? Cold hard cash or lies from the Senate floor?

  3. kiel says:

    No doctor that I know has any idea how much any treatment costs. I’ve asked dozens over the years. They do not know because they do not set the prices–the hospitals, clinics, etc. do. I wish someone would point this out to Lowden.

    If I were in the supposedly left-wing mainstream media, I’d do a story going around to doctors and asking how much stuff costs and whether they would “barter” for services (or even haggle, which is what Lowden meant, until she tried to cover up her own deficient vocabulary by committing herself to bartering). I’m guessing they’d laugh in my face.

  4. sarabeth says:

    Lowden’s chickens-for-checkups proposal has attracted a satisfyingly huge amount of ridicule.

    I think Greg Sargent wins Best-of-Show with: “What a fluster-cluck.”