No Change

(10/24/07):

“To be clear: Barack will support a filibuster of any bill that includes retroactive immunity for telecommunications companies.”

When he changed his position (after securing the nomination, of course) Obama voted for the FISA bill, but said (6/20/08):

It does, however, grant retroactive immunity, and I will work in the Senate to remove this provision so that we can seek full accountability for past offenses.

And now that he’s President:

The Obama administration formally adopted the Bush administration’s position that the courts cannot judge the legality of the National Security Agency’s (NSA’s) warrantless wiretapping program, filing a motion to dismiss Jewel v. NSA late Friday.

In Jewel v. NSA, the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) is challenging the agency’s dragnet surveillance of millions of ordinary Americans. The Obama Justice Department claims in its motion that litigation over the wiretapping program would require the government to disclose privileged “state secrets.” These are essentially the same arguments made by the Bush administration three years ago in Hepting v. AT&T, EFF’s lawsuit against one of the telecom giants complicit in the NSA spying.

How many times does he have to lie and flip-flop on this issue before the same people who chastised Bush speak up?

Comments

  1. sarabeth says:

    It’s worse than that. A lot worse.

    Because anything the Bush administration did, the Obamaphiliacs can do better. A lot better:

    But the Obama DOJ demanded dismissal of the entire lawsuit based on (1) its Bush-mimicking claim that the “state secrets” privilege bars any lawsuits against the Bush administration for illegal spying, and (2) a brand new “sovereign immunity” claim of breathtaking scope — never before advanced even by the Bush administration — that the Patriot Act bars any lawsuits of any kind for illegal government surveillance unless there is “willful disclosure” of the illegally intercepted communications.

    The Bush administration never even conceived of shit like this. Obama says that the government can engage in surveillance that it knows to be illegal, as long as they don’t disclose what they learned. Sorry, don’t deliberately disclose.

    Welcome to the “Oops! Ha-ha-ha!” era of government!

    This man swore a ruddy oath to the Constitution. Twice, if I remember right.

    The Bushies shredded the constitution. The Obamaphiliacs are going to mulch it, and spread it on their lawns as manure.

    And this is the Justice Department that was universally applauded when Obama was making nominations!

  2. matt says:

    why do you hate america?

  3. sarabeth says:

    I know you! You’re the reincarnation of our once-resident-troll, JimC!

  4. Franklin says:

    Obama jumped the shark for me after he failed on FISA last June. I spoke up then, it was no use, and he has jumped many more sharks since then, and will continue to jump more. Such is life.