Change Is A Many-Splendored Thing

In his prime-time press conference on February 9, Barack Obama made it clear that tax cuts were included in the stimulus bill not just to woo Republican support, but because Obama himself wanted them there. As far as Obama was concerned, we needed tax cuts in addition to spending.

Yesterday brought news that Obama also intends to deliver on the corollary of that policy premise. If it’s helpful to cut taxes, it must also be helpful to postpone tax increases. The New York Times reports that that’s exactly what Obama proposes to do, as part of his plan to halve the deficit in four years:

Mr. Obama will also call for letting the Bush tax cuts on income, dividends and capital gains lapse after 2010 for individuals who make more than $250,000 a year. But while the top rate for income would rise to 39.6 percent, the top rate for capital gains and dividends would be 20 percent.

As a candidate, Mr. Obama called for immediately repealing those tax cuts. He decided instead to keep them in place through 2010, as scheduled, reflecting the widespread belief that raising taxes further depresses economic activity.

Wasn’t this one of the cornerstones of his campaign, the immediate repeal of the Bush tax cuts? But, hey, he didn’t break a campaign promise, he just changed his mind.

How’s that believing-in-change thing working for you?

Comments

  1. EVVJSK says:

    See the information at the following link which show the Top income tax rates over the last 100 years. I think many people agree that the period shortly after WWII was one of our most prosperous. At that time, Top tax rate for Top payers was around 90%. I am sure there are some “nuances” that are involved, but it seems to me that the fact that taxes were higher in the past doesn’t necessarily mean that was a bad thing for the country as a whole (I am sure those paying the higher taxes weren’t all that thrilled).
    http://www.ntu.org/main/page.php?PageID=19

  2. Shawnna says:

    I think that as a whole, people aren’t being very fair to President Obama. They expect things to turn around within his first 30 days of office but they fail to realize that this crisis had when brewing for 8 long years. People are torn between whether or not this stimulus is the right thing but at least he is doing something. I feel as long as he’s honest with me about whether or not it is working then I can respect him for having a plan. We should try it out see how it goes and at the first sign that it’s not working fix it promptly or come up with something else. Every great idea didn’t start out a great idea, it had to be tweaked. This is something that we didn’t expect to happen and something that we have never gone through so it’s gonna take time to right the wrongs of the world and I’m willing to be patient and see what the man has to offer. Now if time passes and he lies to us about how well we are doing (think G.W. Bush continuously saying we are winning in Iraq when it is not true b/c) then we will exercise our rights to vote someone else in 4 years.

  3. Mike says:

    CNN has nothing better to do then take a daily poll and publish it as negative. What has Bush done in last 8 years. Give this guy a chance. He has only been there a little over a month and aggressively pushed to come out of this economic disaster that Bush and his Republicans have created. So CNN relax and don’t become a tabloid journalism.

  4. Constanza McNellis says:

    The only reason Obama is having a hard time gaining bipartisanship is because the little Republican boys and girls are going to prove it can’t be done by absolutely refusing to work with the President. After all, their the ones that got us into this mess in the first place and now they want to wipe their hands with Obama and the rest of us.

  5. Kate says:

    Unbelievable that people are bashing Obama for not rescuing the economy quickly enough. The guy has only been in office one month. It will take a lot longer than that to undo the damage of the last 8 years. I think news commentators have too much time on their hands.

  6. sarabeth says:

    It is only because I pray several times daily for strength and forbearance that I am able to restrain myself from replying snappishly to such comments (and I do mean all three of the above).

    None of them has one single thing to do with my post.

    And Mike doesn’t even seem to realize that we are not CNN and have nothing to do with any stories that they may or may not publish.

  7. sarabeth says:

    Overtaken by events, I expand the scope of my previous comment to include all 5.

  8. odie says:

    Does anyone want President Obama to succeed at anything???? So many “uh-huh I gotcha’s”. So much talk about how there is wrong with the stimulus package but no talk of what’s right in it. Some of the Republicans and Democrats act as if the president caused the problems he is trying to clean up. I think it’s a shame and a disgrace that the very group of Republicans on the hill criticizing to no end are the same group of Republicans who allowed this situation to exist.

  9. Carol says:

    sarabeth, I agree with you. That tax cut that the bulk of us are getting is like an allowance that you gave your Jr. High kid. And these folks think that it will help how ?

  10. Eileen says:

    The Obamas being in the white house is testament to how far our country has fallen. Michelle being on the cover of vogue with the caption “The first lady the world has been waiting for” is an insult to every first lady that came before. Get real. She is a racist who had to have her image remade throughout the campaign because she was so damaging. She isn’ t remotely good looking and I can’t stand anything that comes out of her mouth which is why they had to shut her up during the campaign.

  11. tom/pipecock says:

    i believe in change, like how Rove now finally has to answer to the subpoenas requiring him to testify in court. thank god for High Priest Obama.

  12. walter redd says:

    Anybody who doe NOT understnd that it will take more than 30 days to solve so many problems that started thousands of days ago and still going strong is either very stupid or a dead MUGU racist.
    What a shame.

  13. sarabeth says:

    Anybody who could leave comment #12 after reading comment #6 is an asshole.

  14. tom says:

    it will take an infinite number of days to correct any problem if you never take any steps to solve it!!!

  15. Joe the Lib says:

    Good day Sarabeth,
    I’m a little confused about your post. If I interpret it correctly, your calling Mr. Obama a hypocrite for not keeping his campaign promises. Are you saying that he’s the same as the last guys, and that’s a bad thing, or that it’s a good thing? Or are you saying he’s different from the last guys but it’s not a change? Can you maybe do a little compare/contrast to clarify the point?

    That “believing-in-change” thing has always worked for me. I think change is a part of the natural order of things. Even the Catholic Church reinterprets dogma! Can you provide me with your alternative to change? I’m giving great consideration to the things a US citizen would not want changed and my list isn’t very long.

    Both sides want change. I think you argue against the changes you don’t like, which is one of the benefits of living in this great country.

    Now, I tried to find other posts of yours, to see if I could get a crip on your politics, but I couldn’t find any. So I’m going to assume that you are a very concerned citizen that got on the last admin for the “I’m a uniter” talk, and for not vetoing one piece of legislation until his party lost control of Congress. I’m hoping you can send me a cite for a previous post.

    Be well, stay informed, and read to your kids,
    Joe

  16. Joe the Lib says:

    ORRRR, every single post on the site is yours and I’m just ignorant of that. Still can’t tell you political leaning, and I like that.

    After work, I’m checking on the other stuff. Count me in as a regular reader from now on.

    Joe

  17. Eileen says:

    The Obamas in the white house is a testament of how far this country has fallen. Vogue magazine has Michelle on the cover with the caption “The first lady the world has been waiting for” What a joke. What an insult to every real sophisticated, classy, white, first lady that came before. Michelle is a racist who had to have her image remade because nobody could stand her or anything that came out of her big mouth. By the end of four years it will be her that keeps him from getting re-elected. The media keeps trying to tell everyone how beautiful she is, We have eyes and there is nothing good looking about her.

  18. goon says:

    Sara Beth, Do you really think it fair to criticize delivery on campaign promises after only 30 days. The way I see it Obama made stabilizing the economy his first priority and determined repealing bushes tax cuts at this moment in time could hurt public perception of the stability of the economy and weaken it further. This does not mean that the Bush tax cuts are staying through the entirety of Obama’s term and there are still 3 years for the man to keep his word.

    Before you argue that the president shouldn’t be making decisions based on public perception, I would argue that the entire U.S. economy is founded on public perception. If people feel that jobs are in ready supply, and money is easy to come by, no matter the reality of the situation, then they will spend away on all the many services that the U.S.offers. If the perception is the opposite, then people hide all their money under their mattress and write books about the end of the world coming.

  19. Q says:

    Eileen, hmmm it seems to me like you are jealous or Mrs. Obama, like the Republicans are of P. Obama’s popularity! The man has only been in office for a little over 30 days, and everytime he does something the Republicans and Fox news along with alot of the other Bias Media accuse him of everything. 8 years ago your last President Cheated by getting in the White house and went after the guy his Father could not get during his term. Then a ton of lies and misleading information went on while he was in office, alot of people got off the hook, alot of company’s stole their employee’s life savings and ran for it. Your President didn’t offer anything for these American’s. Your Party didn’t offer anything for these American’s and guess what the men that ran away with these American’s money were all Republican, Lieing and misleading and outrage bulling seems to be the way of the Republican Party. You rather let the country go down in flames before you follow the leadership of someone that is not on your side, or trying to be like you. You rather let the poor stay poor while you and your friends stay rich and work us the lower class to death. We have a chance to get this country back on track and here we are fighting cause a Black man is the leader of the Free nation and alot of people don’t like it. Now we see the Republican’s trying to diversify thier image just for a Vote. You guys are a Joke and the Puppets you have chosen to lead your party are a real Joke and if any of them run for President they will not win. Give Up YOu WILL NOT WIN!!!!

  20. Quinton says:

    Eileen, hmmm it seems to me like you are jealous or Mrs. Obama, like the Republicans are of P. Obama’s popularity! The man has only been in office for a little over 30 days, and everytime he does something the Republicans and Fox news along with alot of the other Bias Media accuse him of everything. 8 years ago your last President Cheated by getting in the White house and went after the guy his Father could not get during his term. Then a ton of lies and misleading information went on while he was in office, alot of people got off the hook, alot of company’s stole their employee’s life savings and ran for it.

  21. JV says:

    What a stimulating debate. Where the hell do you get your incoming links from?

  22. tom says:

    this seems like a cnn.com crowd to me.

  23. Joe the Lib says:

    That’s where I found her.