John Aravosis, Shame On You!

Berating Bob Kerrey for “spreading anti-Muslim slurs”, John spreads a nice one himself:

a “madrassa” … is code for “Islamic terrorist training camp”

I’m really appalled to see John Aravosis spouting this kind of demented right-wing garbage.

A madrassa is simply an Islamic religious school. Some of them may be schools in which little children are turned into fundamentalist Muslims. But every fundamentalist Muslim, dear John, is not an Islamic terrorist. At least, not in the eyes of most people who haven’t blindly bought into the hysterical (in both senses of the word) Islamofascist propaganda.

Not sure what he was thinking. But I sincerely hope that John apologizes by the end of the day.

(For the record, even Fox News — back in January when they were helping to spread the original Obama madrassa smear — stopped short of John’s hyperbole:

Fox & Friends host Steve Doocy pointed out that madrassas are “financed by Saudis” and “teach this Wahhabism which pretty much hates us”

Even Doocy stops at: all madrassas breed Wahhabi fundamentalists. On a scale of 1 to 10, where 1 = “A madrassa is an Islamic religious school” and 10 =” A madrassa is code for ‘Islamic terrorist training camp’”, I think Doocy’s statement probably qualifies as a 3. That’s how ashamed of himself I think John needs to be.)

Comments

  1. john says:

    I hate that I have to defend John A., but I think what’s important here is not the precise definition of madrassa, but what a lot of people think it means.

    For the last few years at least, the connotation has been almost exclusively pejorative, right? We don’t often hear the word unless we’re talking about the negative consequences of Islamic education. At least, that’s my impression.

    So I’m not sure if that’s what John A. is trying to say, but I do agree with him that the word has picked up a coded meaning that isn’t exactly positive for a lot of potential voters and isn’t accurate in terms of its actual definition.

  2. sarabeth says:

    If you read John Aravosis’ post, he does not distance himself in any way from the slur.

    There is not a hint of “some people regard madrassa as code for ‘Islamic terrorist training camp’”.

  3. Platitudes says:

    It’s really cute that you try to rationalize what Kerrey did by arguing the semantics of Aravosis’ statement. Atrios has called it “racist dogwhistle politics” but as long as it’s against Obama, who cares right?

    The irony of course, is that you’re both wrong. “Madrassa” is simply the Arabic word for “school”. Before you get anal on someone else’s use of the word you might want to look it up yourself.

    So do you intend to A. Correct your mistake or B. distance yourself from Kerrey’s smears? Or are you just going to continue to miss the point?

  4. sarabeth says:

    By what stretch of distorted logic do you conclude that I rationalized what Kerrey said? (Try to work on reading comprehension, instead of playing sock-puppet games with screen names.)

    I did look it up. I did see that Wikipedia says madrassa is simply the Arabic word for school. The fact remains that in countries like Indonesia or Pakistan it is not used for secular schools, only Islamic schools. In terms of common usage, madrassa does equate to Islamic religious school.

  5. sarabeth says:

    For the record, here’s Wikipedia’s explanation of the word “madrassa”:

    Madrasah (Arabic: مدرسة, madrasa pl. madāris) is the Arabic word for any type of school, secular or religious (of any religion). It has been loaned into various other languages. It is variously transliterated as madrasah, madarasaa, medresa, madrassa, etc. In common English usage the word “madrasah” has been taken to refer to an Islamic religious school.

    Are you going to shit-and-run as usual, or are you going to respond for a change?

  6. matt says:

    Are you going to shit-and-run as usual, or are you going to respond for a change?

    this will be the end if it’s the former.